// Recipes

Leftover Chicken Tortilla Soup

Char the vegetables black, fry the puree until the oil separates, and whatever chicken is left in the fridge becomes the best soup of the week.

🍲 Serves 6–10 ⏱️ ~70 min 🍗 Uses leftover chicken 🚫 MSG-free
A spoonful of chicken tortilla soup lifted from the bowl with melted Monterey Jack pulling behind it

Instructions

  1. Soak the anchos

    Tear the anchos into a blender with 2 cups of the broth. Let them soften about 15 minutes.

  2. Roast the garlic

    Cut the top off the head of garlic, drizzle with olive oil, wrap it in foil, and roast at 400°F for 35–45 minutes until the cloves are soft enough to squeeze out. Start this first — it's the longest thing in the recipe, and everything else happens while it's in the oven.

  3. Char the vegetables

    Dry skillet, high heat, no oil. Onion cut-side down, jalapeños alongside. Take them well past brown to actual black in spots — that char is the smoke in this soup.

  4. Deglaze the pan

    Pull the vegetables out and pour the whole can of diced tomatoes straight into the hot skillet. Scrape everything stuck to the bottom up into the tomatoes.

  5. Blend the puree

    Into the blender with the soaking anchos goes the charred onion and jalapeños, the roasted garlic (oil and all), the tomatoes from the pan, the chipotles and adobo, the crushed tortilla chips, cumin, and oregano. Blend a full minute — you want it completely smooth, not almost smooth.

  6. Fry the puree

    Heat the peanut oil in a pot until it shimmers, then pour in the puree — stand back, it spatters. Fry about 8 minutes, stirring. It's done when it darkens to a deep brick color, holds a trail behind the spoon, and the oil starts breaking out around the edges. This step is the whole recipe. Don't shortcut it.

  7. Simmer

    Add the remaining 4 cups of broth and the salt. Simmer uncovered about 20 minutes.

  8. Corn, beans, chicken

    Stir in the frozen corn, drained black beans, and diced chicken. Heat 3–4 minutes and no longer — the chicken is already cooked, and boiling it again just dries it out. Off the heat, squeeze in both limes, then taste and adjust salt.

  9. Build the bowls

    Chips in the bottom of the bowl first, soup ladled over them, toppings last. The chips underneath go soft and thicken the soup; the ones on top stay crunchy. You want both.

The two things that matter

  • Char to black, not brown. A dry skillet on high heat is all you need. If you've got a gas flame or a bed of charcoal ash, even better — but blackened is blackened.
  • Fry until the oil separates. That's the visual cue that the puree has cooked out and concentrated. Pull it early and the soup tastes thin and raw.

No leftover chicken?

  • Grocery store rotisserie chicken, pulled off the bone — fastest option.
  • Canned chicken, drained. Works fine in a soup this bold.
  • Raw breasts in a crock pot with a cup of the broth, then diced or shredded.
  • Diced holds up better than shredded here, especially if the chicken came off a grill or a smoker.

Going the extra mile

  • Cut corn tortillas into strips and fry them yourself instead of using bagged chips for the garnish.
  • Crumbled queso fresco in place of the Monterey Jack.
  • Neither one is required. The soup is already better than most restaurant versions without them.
Bowl of chicken tortilla soup loaded with shredded Monterey Jack, diced avocado, sour cream, cilantro, and crumbled tortilla chips

Toppings go on last — chips underneath, chips on top.

You might also like

See all recipes →